Thursday, December 11, 2008
An end of the week almost mezze platter
Shmuel Rosner on Why American Jews Need to Change This is a great interview, and prompted a recollection of his speaking engagement here in Berkeley last year.
I have developed a small affection for the world of neuro-cognitive studies. I first heard of the field from Matar Davis, who graduated from Cal a few years ago (she is currently in Israel, completing her Army service) and then picked up a book on the historical origins of neurology [Soul Made Flesh: The Discovery of the Brain--and How it Changed the World] and have found myself reading articles on the subject whenever I stumble across them. This one is from the Times this past week and concerns what scientists are learning about the sense of touch. Primal, Acute and Easily Duped: Our Sense of Touch Also on that front was the obit of a man who had amnesia for most of his life, and it made him a well known fixture for researchers- but he never knew it for more than a few minutes. H. M., an Unforgettable Amnesiac
Here's a new slogan for you "Turn it to the Left". It's not political, its part of a campaign to get people to turn the volume down on their Ipods and other devices before they have permanently damaged their hearing. Here's an article on the subject, no listening required. All That Noise Is Damaging Children’s Hearing
Been debating a Detroit bail-out at the bar this week? Here's something to add to the mix of facts and opinions swirling in your cortex: $73 an Hour: Adding It Up
Ok, get back to your studies.
Thursday, December 4, 2008
A slew of reading
Once you have dealt with that reality you might want to switch gears, so have a drink. Highland Friends to Warm the Night
On a sadder note, in light of the attacks in Mumbai last week there was a nice story in the Times about the Jewish communities of India. Worth reading if only to help break down the binary of Ashkanaz/Sepharad (Jews are from more places than Germany and Spain). Jews of Mumbai, a Tiny and Eclectic Group, Suddenly Reconsider Their Serene Existence
Now, some of you will no doubt come to the conclusion that I seem to read the New York Times exclusively- while that isn't true (I also read a bunch of other stuff- including Bicycling, Gourmet and Outside Magazines) I was brought up in a home where the Times was simply known as "the paper" and despite the fact that my parents have not lived in the five boroughs in my lifetime, New York was "the city". So, my apologies to the champions of the Washington Post, the Boston Globe and others.
As a small token of my pluralism here is an op-ed from the LA Times written by former Israel politician Avrum Burg. He is someone I have had the pleasure to meet, and while I never voted for him, he is a provocative thinker on the Israeli intellectual scene. Holocaust's unholy hold
And this I simply stumbled across while looking for the link to the piece above. An op-ed about the issue of Biblical Archeology and fakes. I remember reading about the arrests in this case, but not what had happened since. As a former student of Archeology I was saddened to hear about this turn of events.
Hoaxes from the Holy Land
Last but not least, is this op-ed from the Jerusalem Post. Written by Aaron David Miller (who I met once years ago) who worked for many years in the US State Department and was the Executive Director of Seeds for Peace- an effort to bring Israeli and Palestinian teenagers together. An Israeli-Palestinian agreement: Forget about it A hat tip to Jeff Goldberg at the Atlantic for the link, as I no longer read the Post regularly.
Thursday, October 2, 2008
A New Year's Wish
The high holidays are interesting to me, not from a theological perspective, but from one of anthropology. It happens that these holidays rank among the top three Jewish experiences/rituals performed by an average Jew in the course of a year. Any guesses as to the other two? (it’s Hanukah and Passover).
So, we could assume then that the three most important events in the Jewish calendar are in fact the High Holidays, Hanukah, and Passover.
Yet when you examine the Torah (a.k.a the five books of Moses)you discover something interesting. First off, Hanukkah is not there at all- it is a holiday whose origins are hundreds of years after not only the Torah, but also the destruction of the first temple in 586 BCE and it subsequent reconstruction starting in the 530’s. And to hear the Torah tell it the really big days are the Hagim.
So what is a Hag? Hag comes from the same semitic root as the Arabic word Haj. The Haj of course is a pilgrimage. A Hag is also a pilgrimage, not to anywhere, but to the temple itself in Jerusalem. We are commanded to perform explicit rituals on three occasions during the year. [Name those holidays- Sukkot, Passover and Shavuot] So, what are the other holy days? And why has this set in particular gained such a wide following and resonance?
I believe that this “birthday for creation” has so much appeal because it is at its base as much conditioned on the relationships between people as the relationship between people and God. In fact I will go a step further and say that even for people who have difficulty with the concept of a God who actively intervenes in human history this holiday can be a great resonator.
So what is it about this holiday? This first day of the year that falls according to the Torah on the tenth day of the seventh month (meaning Yom Kippur)? In case you are wondering that would make the actual New Year on the first of Nissan, about two weeks before Passover each year.
So let’s ask ourselves what are the prime obligations of this cycle? Well, for Rosh Hashanah, our only hard obligation is to hear the Shofar blown. Why? That is not clear, but many commentators describe it as a wake up call for Yom Kippur. As George Carlin said, “this is your one minute warning; get your s--t together”.
And what of Yom Kippur, why the wake up call, the fasting and the long day of caffeine withdrawal? What is the obligation? Concisely put, it is to push us to consider the relationships we have with our fellow human beings.
So, how are your relationships? How is the relationship you have with your parents, siblings, extended family, roommates, classmates, lab partners, sorority sisters, fellow student leaders, professors and everyone else in your life? Let me urge you all to take some time and think about how you and your community interact. Finally let me urge you to move a step beyond those individual relationships and consider what you and your community can do in this coming year to make the world a place in which the list of sins for which we ask atonement will be shorter.
Shana tova u’mituka
A good and sweet year.
Friday, September 12, 2008
Got Votes?
In recent weeks I have heard people (who are very smart, well educated Cal students) offer a number of incredibly lame excuses for not being registered (with my favorite that they are trying to avoid jury duty). ARE YOU SERIOUS?? Listen, at the risk of sounding like the old man I am becoming let me tell you that voting is not an option, not a privilege- but an OBLIGATION.
This style of government (termed a representative democracy) functions at its best when the electorate (that's you) participates. Otherwise we cease to enjoy the rule of the majority- but rather the tyranny of the minority. Don't believe me? Let's do some simple math. In 2004 voter turnout was 64% (higher than it had been in several cycles). George Bush won that election with 51% (Kerry had 48%). So, that means on the basis of the votes of 30.7% of the voters we selected someone to serve as the leader of the country. That 30% is the good news, by what percentage was your mayor or local judge elected? Off year elections have turnouts that are almost criminally negligent. In many countries voter turnout routinely runs over 80%. The last Israeli general election was 63%- the lowest in Israel's history- still higher than our "record high" in 2004.
So, take a moment and think "am I registered to vote?". If the answer is "no" then you need to come by, get a form and take care of it. This country is an important place, lets not leave it in the hands of only 30% of the voting public.
All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good people to do nothing*
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, September 5, 2008
In the Image of God - Genesis 1:27
From this simple passage there developed a Jewish precept that we are all made in the image of God, and therefore contain within in us a spark of that holiness. This includes not only those who are holy in their own lives- but all of humanity regardless of their actions, beliefs or desires.
So, you might ask "what should this mean to me?" A question lifted straight from the Passover tradition. What I would say to you is this, treat each person as worthy of the respect you would extend to the creator. I would be the first to add that this is a enormous task and demands much of ourselves. After all we are often caught up in the emotional environments we inhabit. Can a Democrat and a Republican see each other this way? Can a secular Jew and devout Christian? Can you look at your ex-girl/boy friend this way? And what if we cannot? Then what?
The answer unfortunately is that when we no longer can see that divine spark in our fellow, our rival, our enemy, then they become less than human. History is too thickly littered with examples of this to be tossed aside as mere conflation. The Crusades, Darfur, The Holocaust, Cambodia, and many other tragedies on scales immense and tiny should motivate all of us to, as Rabbi Yishmael said, "greet every person with a cheerful manner". (Pirkai Avot 3:19) and in the words of Rabbi Tarfon "You are not obligated to finish the task, neither are you free to neglect it" (Pirkai Avot 2:21)
So, go forth make community and seek that spark of the divine in the people who populate your life, both near and far.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, August 29, 2008
Community
One might argue that the Jewish people have in fact taken the idea of community to several new and innovative levels. I lived for 5 years on kibbutz. The first kibbutz was simply a mechanism for survival. Small groups of young workers banded together and pooled their earnings to ensure that even when some members were not working, everyone still ate. Later as they achieved a modicum of economic security (this was a result of acquiring some land) they moved beyond simple survival to think carefully about what kinds of communities they wanted to live in. One can only surmise that the Jewish experience with community was a powerful influence on their choices. But the ideas to see to the collective care of children, the collective health of members and collective emotional well being of the community are still at the forefront of communitarian thinking.
I was reminded of this incredible communal impulse this past week. I was at a funeral, and the Rabbi reminded us that the act of attending to the deceased is one that we make with no hope of direct reciprocity and one that we can in no way ensure for ourselves beyond setting an expectation with our own behavior.
All of which brings me back to campus. This week there were hundreds of first year students, scores of seniors and many more sophomores and juniors all seeking (or reconnecting with) community. What will this new year of Jewish communities look like? That will depend largely on their members. But my wish for them is that they are communities that are meaningful, sincere and enduring.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, August 22, 2008
Welcome Back
When we played that game I can tell you with all honesty that I never expected to be here. I had never thought of living in California, hadn't even been here since I was 9 and would have laughed like crazy if you had suggested that I would be working for the Jewish Student Center at Cal.
Having said all that, one of the most important lessons I learned over the course of nearly 20 years of work and several different career twists is this; Where you end up has less to do with what you know, and more to do with what you learn. What does that mean you ask? When I started college I had an idea of going into Criminal Justice work, two years in I realized that I loved the study of History more than recidivism rates. Later I would find myself completing a MA in History, while working as a caseworker within the County Jail- life takes you odd places. I imagined a next step in getting a Ph.D. but the trip to Israel to learn Hebrew took me into Jewish Education, and that started me down a path that has led here.
I didn't know this path even existed 20 years ago, and only started to see it 10 years ago. But today I know this is a path of reward, satisfaction and meaning for me. I hope that each member of the Class of 2012 has a chance to look up from their studies (hard, I know) and see if their path still feels right.
And everyone else- welcome back, we missed you.
Wednesday, May 14, 2008
Save the Earth, Bike to Work (school, whatever)
As many of you know, I am a pretty hard core bike commuter- I ride year round (not such a huge bragging point here in NorCal) and find that it leaves me pretty energetic even when the days are short, the work long and the week longer still.
One of the great things about a bike commute is that you actually have time to see things. I travel one of the bike paths for a few miles of my commute and each week I see a lot of the same people. There is the guy who has been learning to roller blade for several years now, he skates with dumbbells in his hands for some reason (arm strength?). There is the older guy who seems to be towing his grandkids in a trailer to preschool, he smokes while he rides- very un-California. There are the folks walking to the BART stations, the joggers and of course the middle school kids walking six across (hard to get around them). I watch homes get renovated, businesses open (and close) and see the trees leaf, flowers bloom and lawns die in the summer.
It might need pointing out (but I doubt it) that biking is much easier on your wallet and the earth than a car and unless you have very odd circumstances, easier to park. Of course all of this works here in the Bay area- ranked as one of the best cycling places in North American (Portland holds top honors) but not in other places. I used to bike commute in Milwaukee and while the paths were ok, the weather was a killer.
So, as you head out into the work world for a summer or the rest of your life take a moment and really think about the relationship between where you live and where you work and how you can cover that distance in a way that makes you happy, as opposed to giving you road rage.
Have a great summer.
Tuesday, April 22, 2008
Know before what you sit
This year I spent a lot of time thinking about what would reside (albeit briefly) upon my Pesach dinner plate. I grew up on a farm and was never unclear on where meat (and for that matter potatoes) came from. Long ago I made peace with the notion that the fat and protein resting on my plate was once a breathing creature. Having said that, like most people who have driven past the feed lot on the 5 I feel a bit uneasy about the provenance of that meat. Kosher meat is meat that has been slaughtered in the ritual manner of slicing through all of the major blood vessels in the neck in one blow, thus reducing the pain and "tearing" of the animal to a minimum (trafe means torn or ripped). But kashrut is silent on the matter of how that animal is raised and what it eats. This led me to seek out grass fed organic kosher meat for our family seder this year. I ended up choosing bison, as much for the experience as anything else.
The meal was fantastic. The combination of family, great food and good conversation made for a truly wonderful evening. Much of what I served was sourced from California (the bison came from Montana) and I felt that I honored an ethical imperative that is contained in the laws of kashrut. But, I would also be the first to tell you that that it is an ethical imperative that is not contained in the text of the commandment and there lots of room for discussion on the matter.
As for myself, I a hoping that Niman ranch meats will consider adding a kosher line to its products. I have a well seasoned cast iron pan just waiting to put a nice crust on a thick steak.
Wednesday, April 9, 2008
A thought for Passover- eat beans!
Eating Kitniyot (Legumes) on Pesach
(OH 453:1)
Question:
In light of the ingathering of the exiles, would it be possible to eliminate the Ashkenazic custom of not eating legumes on Pesach?
Responsum:
1) In our opinion it is permitted (and perhaps even obligatory) to eliminate this custom. It is in direct contradiction to an explicit decision in the Babylonian Talmud (Pesachim 114b) and is also in contradiction to the opinion of all the sages of the Mishnah and Talmud except one (R.Yochanan ben Nuri, Pesahim 35a and parallels). It also contradicts the theory and the practice of the Amoraim both in Babylonia and in Israel (Pesahim 114b and other sources), the Geonim (Sheiltot, Halakhot Pesukot, Halakhot Gedolot, etc.) and of most of the early medieval authorities in all countries (altogether more than 50 Rishonim!).
2) This custom is mentioned for the first time in France and Provence in the beginning of the thirteenth century by R. Asher of Lunel, R. Samuel of Falaise, and R. Peretz of Corbeil - from there it spread to various countries and the list of prohibited foods continued to expand. Nevertheless, the reason for the custom was unknown and as a result many sages invented at least eleven different explanations for the custom. As a result, R. Samuel of Falaise, one of the first to mention it, referred to it as a "mistaken custom" and R. Yerucham called it a "foolish custom".
3) Therefore, the main halakhic question in this case is whether it is permissible to do away with a mistaken or foolish custom. Many rabbinic authorities have ruled that it is permitted (and perhaps even obligatory) to do away with this type of "foolish custom" (R. Abin in Yerushalmi Pesahim, Maimonides, the Rosh, the Ribash, and many others). Furthermore, there are many good reasons to do away with this "foolish custom": a) It detracts from the joy of the holiday by limiting the number of permitted foods; b) It causes exorbitant price rises, which result in "major financial loss" and, as is well known, "the Torah takes pity on the people of Israel's money"; c) It emphasizes the insignificant (legumes) and ignores the significant (hametz, which is forbidden from the five kinds of grain); d) It causes people to scoff at the commandments in general and at the prohibition of hametz in particular - if this custom has no purpose and is observed, then there is no reason to observe other commandments; e) Finally, it causes unnecessary divisions between Israel's different ethnic groups. On the other hand, there is only one reason to observe this custom: the desire to preserve an old custom. Obviously, this desire does not override all that was mentioned above. Therefore, both Ashkenazim and Sephardim are permitted to eat legumes and rice on Pesah without fear of transgressing any prohibition.
4) Undoubtedly, there will be Ashkenazim who will want to stick to the "custom of their ancestors" even though they know that it is permitted to eat legumes on Pesah. To them we recommend that they observe only the original custom of not eating rice and legumes but that they use oil from legumes and all the other foods "forbidden" over the years, such as peas, beans, garlic, mustard, sunflower seeds, peanuts etc. Thus they will be able to eat hundreds of products, which bear the label "Kosher for Pesah for those who eat legumes." This will make their lives easier and will add joy and pleasure to their observance of Pesah.
Rabbi David Golinkin
Approved Unanimously 5749
Thursday, March 20, 2008
Civic, civil, society
Robert Putnam, author of "Bowling Alone" an exploration of America's decline in civil societal structures spoke of two types of associations. The first is a bonding association, that is one that brings people who have a strong common denominator together. Hillel is a good example of that, since it serves to build Jewish community another good example is Knights of Columbus, a Catholic Fraternal Order. The second type is called a bridging association. These bring people together who have a weak common denominator. Dialog groups, some types of trade and professional organizations are examples of this. Putnam puts forth the idea that bridging organizations can only thrive when people from strong bonding organizations take part. So the take away is that in order to have inter-communal dialog, you have to start of with strong communities and then build a bridge between them.
Putnam also offered some good news in contrast to his book (published in 2000). He said that the generation that came of age during the last few years (perhaps with 9/11 as a catalyst) has demonstrated a strong shift towards civic engagement and civil society. This is a reversal of a 30 year trend in the other direction. These young people are the backbone of the campus civil society right now. The shifts in American communal life have only begun to be felt and this may be the first presidential election where their impact is felt across the country.
I'm pretty excited, as the engaged fraction of a generation better known for our slacking than our achievements (somehow people think of Kurt Cobain more that Gavin Newsom when you say Gen X). I look forward to seeing this new wave build.
In the meantime I am home spending some time with my own bonding
group (my family) and enjoying the California sunshine. Have a Shabbat Shalom, and for everyone who taking part in ASUC elections, remember to pack some sunscreen with your sidewalk chalk.
Thursday, March 13, 2008
My Zionist Fantasy
I remember the first time I was confronted with this view point. I was living in Arad attending Ulpan (Hebrew language instruction) and one of the instructors introduced me to a young woman who was in training to become a Shalicha (emissary) of the Jewish Agency (a large NGO that provides an array of educational and support services inside Israel and around the Jewish world). She asked my friend if he was planning to move to Israel permanently. Since he had been in Israel for all of a month at that point he said that he was not planning to. She then looked at him and said, "ah so you are not a Zionist". He took issue with that since he considered himself a Zionist, had been active in pro-Israel issues as a student (back during the first Intifada) and thought that his plans for moving to Israel (or not) were really not part of the discussion.
It was from that discussion (and many more like it) that I started think about my own Zionist journey. I did move to Israel, for what I thought was the rest of my life. I lived for 5 years on Kibbutz and savored every moment of it. I returned to America, not bitter- but really grateful for the experience I had.
As a Jewish educator I was often having conversations with others about Israel's role in their lives and its impact on their Judaism. Today I have a Zionist vision for Jews from America. That vision is for every American Jew to spend a year living in Israel.
Why? Because I know that after a year of holidays, political conversations with cab drivers, discussions with religious and non-religious Israelis you will have a set of experiences that will change your Jewish identity. Will you move to Israel permanently (make Aliyah)? I don't know, but you will spend a year wrestling with the question and from that emerge with a stronger, deeper and more thoughtful approach to Jewish and Judaism.
So, let me make a plug now for the Masa scholarship program (link) and an offer to talk to anyone about their thoughts on the matter.
Saturday, March 8, 2008
Someone did it better
If you ever were tempted to think about how that list might be re-imagined in 2008, then you should read this article in last weekend's New York Times.
As for me, its shabbat and I am resting.
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Mivchan Amerikai
Judaism is:
1) a religion
2) an ethnic group
3) a condition
4) a civilization
This question was prompted by the recent poll on religious life in America (see the NYT article here). The poll revealed the degree to which Americans were increasingly changing religious affiliation over the course of their lifetimes. Where once people had largely participated (or abstained from) the religion of their family, it was more common for people to "shop around" for a style of faith and practice that suited them. The biggest net growth was for the unaffiliated, people who did not profess any religious participation at all.
"The presentation of Judaism will be judged by the adequacy of the statement establishing its truth" Eugene Borowitz, Choices in Modern Jewish Thought (Behrman House, 1995)Judaism is often seen by both Jews and non-Jews as purely a religion. That prompts the question as to what degree we find Judaism as a religion a compelling answer to our theological needs. Our preception of that is directly rooted in how well we understand Judaism to begin with. For the vast majority of us our Jewish education either never was, or ended at age 13. So regardless of what our theological needs are, we are almost universally under-equipped to asses Judaism's usefulness. If we are devoted to the idea of advancing Judaism purely as a religion then we will have to undertake a huge amount of remedial education within the next generation.
Judaism however is not just a religion. In both the ancient and modern nationalist perspective Jews are a people. Whether one subscribes to the biblical narrative or not, the emergence of a distinctive nation state in antiquity is well established in the historical record. The literature, physical remains and legislative work of those kingdoms survived and the descendants of those people have maintained a distinctive language, religious system and set of cultural mores. While these were influenced by the various communities Jews lived in, the rate of assimilation was low and the majority of the Jewish communities had more in common with each other than the people they lived amongst. This was true up to the enlightenment period. From that time until the Shoah, western Jews sought to heighten their connection to their land of residence and minimize their connections with Jews from other places. The Zionist movement was a notable exception to this, but its size and influence were small before WWII.
Another notable American exception to that was Rabbi Mordchai Kalplan. Kaplan defined Judaism in his seminal 1934 work as a "Civilization". He sought in that moment to undo the western Jews self-redefinition and reassert the non-religious components of Jewish life and Judaism.
Which leads us back to our test, what is Judaism- to you?
Now that you have that answer let me ask you something else-
What are you doing about it now?
Judaism is no longer a condition but a choice. - Richard Joel, President of Yeshiva University
Thursday, February 21, 2008
Total Eclipse
I experienced another smaller miracle this week, but not the kind that should be exceptional. I was riding home on Tuesday night and some combination of pothole/rear wheel/chain resulted in my hitting the rain soaked pavement in front of the RSF at 15MPH or so.
Those moments of the fall are so clear while they transpire. I can still recall the slowness with which I felt myself leave the bike and descend to the street. My hands where in front of me and the bike somewhere behind. I remember hitting the pavement with my left side and then sliding for a bit before snapping back into the moment with the sudden realization that I was laying in the middle of a busy street.
I was ok, some scrapes and a lot of bruises, including a fabulous one on the heel of my right hand, still hurt. But I was shaken enough to use BART to cover most of the remaining distance between there and my kitchen table.
What struck me in the aftermath were the people who stopped and offered to help. I didn't have the presence of mind to be as thankful as I should have, so I want to thank them now (whether they read me or not). In the cold wet night on a busy street people in cars and on foot stopped to ask if I was ok, if I needed help and one even brought me a wad of handlebar tape that had peeled off my bike and was laying in the gutter.
The next day (Wednesday) dawned with the threat of rain, and even rained on me during my ride in adding nothing to my recovery -even making me feel more sore. But by lunch the sun had come out clear and bright. Lunch with a good friend was superb and the rest of the day went well. I missed the lunar eclipse, but having seen the compassion of my fellow man I was already a witness to a small miracle and that is the thought I will take into this Shabbat.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Shabbat
So let me tell you about my plans for Shabbat. First off, for the first time in a month I will be home with my family. I am thinking about making a nice piece of seared tuna (that way we can use the dairy dishes and put butter on the table), some blanched broccoli and perhaps a fritata. There are a couple bottles of red wine gathering dust in the rack, so one of those will come to the table as well. Tomorrow I plan to sleep until my kids come and wake me up (hopefully sometime after 9- but we'll see) and then to spend the day doing almost nothing that I need to do. Who knows, perhaps I can squeeze a ride in. I just registered for a 112 mile ride in May, so I need to get in shape.
It's a three day weekend, the weather is supposed to be great. Don't stay inside trying to catch up on your reading, go out and soak up some of that vitaman D (don't forget your sunscreen) and have a peaceful, relaxing and meaningful Shabbat.
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
Jew-ish?
“For me “Israeli’ is the authentic, complete and consummate word for the concept ‘Jewish’! Israeli-ness is the total, perfect and original Judaism, one that should provide answers in all areas of life.”
A.B. Yehoshua
Sleeping on a Wire, David Grossman (FSG, 1993)
I have always loved that quote. It manages to be at once completely provocative and seemingly quite normal. A conversation that I often have with other staff members and students revolves around how Jewish is Berkeley Hillel. The classic rejoinder is, "what does Jewish mean?" Unfortunately I do not have as clear an answer as Mr. Yehoshua.
What I can offer instead is my own 30+ year long struggle to define my own Judaism. The questions I have wrestled with (everything from kashrut to theology) have informed how I live my life now and how I contribute to the education of my children. One thing I have learned is that none of us can offer the other anything more than an example of the struggle. My answers will not be yours and my reasons will not suffice for your life. My professional mission is to encourage each student and staff member to fully engage in that struggle. To bring to it all of the intellectual firepower that they bring to class and to not allow their Judaism to simply sit on a shelf.The flip side of that is there are those who have a pretty set idea of what Jewish looks like. Whether from a more traditional, or more liberal perspective they seek in Berkeley Hillel a replication of themselves. This is pretty natural since we all seek ourselves in community. After all, how easy is it to become part of a community that is completely foreign? So, how can an institution be both challenging and welcoming? How can we be both home-like and new? That is a challenge that we face every day.
"Lo alecha ham'lacha ligmor,V'lo atah ven chorin l'hibateil mi-menah."
It is not on you to finish the work, but nor are you free to leave it.
Pirkai Avot (Ethics of our Fathers) 2:16
Saturday, February 2, 2008
Imagined Communities
What he meant by that was not that the students did not exist, but rather that anything we thought we knew about them was pure supposition. Their likes, dislikes, thoughts about Jewish community and Judaism were simply educated guesses on our part and nothing more. This comes as a shock to most of us in the field, because we like to think we know why people don't come around.
The answers include that we are too social, not social enough, too Jewish, not Jewish enough, too liberal, not liberal enough and so on. But is any of that true? Do we really have any idea what those barriers are that prevent them from joining the intentional communities we create?
Surveys conducted over the last few years reveal that most of our ideas are wrong. What we learn is that for most people the real question is how high is their sense of Jewish identification, and how motivated are they to act on that feeling. People who score high on both axes tend to become very involved. Those who score very low on either, don't.
Of course the secondary question is whether those score in the middle on both can find a micro-community within our larger framework that looks and feels sufficiently familiar to be claimed as their own. This is the moment that our professional skills are tested as we attempted to facilitate this matching process. Do it well and the community expands. Do it poorly and we leave someone with a real barrier to joining the Jewish community and that's not imaginary.
Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Anton Ego celebrates Tu b'Shvat
Memories are like that, some are incredibly powerful in their recall and arrive full force in the here and now. Today is the 15th of Shvat, or in Hebrew shorthand "Tu" (meaning 10+5 or 15). California's Mediterranean climate at this time of year prompts thoughts of mid-winter in Israel. When the first rains arrive the hillsides of the Judean foothills (where I lived for 5 years) are painted a bright green of new vegetation. In the weeks that follow there are successive waves of red, purple, and yellow as those plants flower. The air is so filled with pollen that some of my friends would hide indoors for weeks and my porch was covered with a dusting of yellow each afternoon.
The first sign of Spring (and Tu B'Shvat) is the flowering of the almond trees. With crisp white and soft pink blooms these trees announce themselves at the field edges and along the roads. If the rain lets up for a week you can pilot a mountain bike down the narrow canyons the run from the edge of Jerusalem towards the sea. In those rapid, undulating descents you zip past artifacts of Jewish civilization from King David to Arik Sharon. From the top of the ridge above the old city the highlands of Ammon, Moab and Edom are so clear and crisp you think it would be an easy afternoon walk to Jordan.
The sudden intrusion of a passing car snaps me back into the here and now. The bay is not the Mediterranean, San Francisco is not Tel Aviv, and this busy street is not Nachal Kesalon. Anton Ego found a way to bring his past to his present, and as a Zionist who no longer lives in Zion I try to do the same.
Saturday, January 19, 2008
The Big Easy
As I have noted before, I am in the business of creating Jewish community. When you take a group of people half way across the country, plop them down in a new place and set them to common task then community is all but inevitable. There is a point in each of these trips where the pronouns shift. People stop using "I" and replace it with "we". That change, while hard to pin point in the moment, is so powerful that it makes the difference between success and failure in a trip like this. The first time I really noticed it was on the first trip we did last year. My work team was responsible for making breakfast on Thursday. I was perhaps 15 minutes late getting out of bed and feared that I would arrive in the dining hall to either see no one, or worse people just sitting around waiting to be told what to do. I arrived in the kitchen and was delighted to find everyone there, hard at work making breakfast for the other 2/3rds of the group still waking up. The idea of collective responsibility had taken deep root in the Louisiana mud.
Of course that is not the only reason we invest so much time, money and expertise in these trips. Alongside the community building is a chance to put the Jewish value of Justice (tzedek) to practical use. The opportunity to meet people who are still living in a FEMA trailers alongside the shell of their home and by the sweat of our own brows get them closer to living some semblance of a normal life is incredibly rewarding. The common refrain I have heard from the citizens of the gulf is "material possessions mean a lot less than we thought". A powerful message in an age of consumerism, but a painful way to learn it. The smiles and thanks they express for our unskilled, but energetic labor makes up for the steel cots, hard rain and mosquitoes that seems to travel in vast swarms.
Of course the trips never happen by themselves. They are the result of huge amounts of hard work by fellow staff members. Three times now, I have had the thrill of watching people grow their abilities, stretch professionally and enjoy the fruit of well earned success.
Eventually New Orleans will recover, our work there will cease, but the memories, experiences and satisfaction will stay with me forever.
Wednesday, January 16, 2008
Management by Metallica?
Part of the challenge with blogging is trying to stay current with what swims in my head. Too much time off and I am finding that I have more potential material than I can work into a single post (and I struggle to find the time to do what I do).
Anyhow, last night I watched "Some kind of Monster" a documentary released in 2004 about the struggles the band Metallica went through to record the album "St. Anger". It is a really fascinating look at how people can work together for years (in this case over 20) and still not really be friends in the sense of the word most of us would understand. Watching these guys try to overcome their many years of patterned behavior and confront the long standing interpersonal issues is a useful lesson for anyone who hopes to lead a group of people (professional or volunteer).
Leadership/management and whatever else you want to call it is easily the most difficult thing that happens in any workplace. The subtle process of building collaboration, consensus and then owning the hard decisions is hard. It takes a willingness to confront your own mistakes, hear criticism and not become defensive. It requires that you move beyond your comfort zone and recognize when you are not the smartest person for the issue at hand.
I recently attended a workshop on building a great place to work. The single most important thing I learned is that when people trust and are trusted, then all of the other things we would expect are secondary (money, time off, fancy chairs, etc). Watching Lars and James learn to trust each other (and themselves) is a powerful lesson.
My own challenges have become clearer after seeing their's.