Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Jew-ish?

“For me “Israeli’ is the authentic, complete and consummate word for the concept ‘Jewish’! Israeli-ness is the total, perfect and original Judaism, one that should provide answers in all areas of life.”

A.B. Yehoshua

Sleeping on a Wire, David Grossman (FSG, 1993) New York. p.253



I have always loved that quote. It manages to be at once completely provocative and seemingly quite normal. A conversation that I often have with other staff members and students revolves around how Jewish is Berkeley Hillel. The classic rejoinder is, "what does Jewish mean?" Unfortunately I do not have as clear an answer as Mr. Yehoshua.

What I can offer instead is my own 30+ year long struggle to define my own Judaism. The questions I have wrestled with (everything from kashrut to theology) have informed how I live my life now and how I contribute to the education of my children. One thing I have learned is that none of us can offer the other anything more than an example of the struggle. My answers will not be yours and my reasons will not suffice for your life. My professional mission is to encourage each student and staff member to fully engage in that struggle. To bring to it all of the intellectual firepower that they bring to class and to not allow their Judaism to simply sit on a shelf.

The flip side of that is there are those who have a pretty set idea of what Jewish looks like. Whether from a more traditional, or more liberal perspective they seek in Berkeley Hillel a replication of themselves. This is pretty natural since we all seek ourselves in community. After all, how easy is it to become part of a community that is completely foreign? So, how can an institution be both challenging and welcoming? How can we be both home-like and new? That is a challenge that we face every day.

"Lo alecha ham'lacha ligmor,V'lo atah ven chorin l'hibateil mi-menah."
It is not on you to finish the work, but nor are you free to leave it.
Pirkai Avot (Ethics of our Fathers) 2:16

No comments:

Post a Comment