Judaism is:
1) a religion
2) an ethnic group
3) a condition
4) a civilization
This question was prompted by the recent poll on religious life in America (see the NYT article here). The poll revealed the degree to which Americans were increasingly changing religious affiliation over the course of their lifetimes. Where once people had largely participated (or abstained from) the religion of their family, it was more common for people to "shop around" for a style of faith and practice that suited them. The biggest net growth was for the unaffiliated, people who did not profess any religious participation at all.
"The presentation of Judaism will be judged by the adequacy of the statement establishing its truth" Eugene Borowitz, Choices in Modern Jewish Thought (Behrman House, 1995)Judaism is often seen by both Jews and non-Jews as purely a religion. That prompts the question as to what degree we find Judaism as a religion a compelling answer to our theological needs. Our preception of that is directly rooted in how well we understand Judaism to begin with. For the vast majority of us our Jewish education either never was, or ended at age 13. So regardless of what our theological needs are, we are almost universally under-equipped to asses Judaism's usefulness. If we are devoted to the idea of advancing Judaism purely as a religion then we will have to undertake a huge amount of remedial education within the next generation.
Judaism however is not just a religion. In both the ancient and modern nationalist perspective Jews are a people. Whether one subscribes to the biblical narrative or not, the emergence of a distinctive nation state in antiquity is well established in the historical record. The literature, physical remains and legislative work of those kingdoms survived and the descendants of those people have maintained a distinctive language, religious system and set of cultural mores. While these were influenced by the various communities Jews lived in, the rate of assimilation was low and the majority of the Jewish communities had more in common with each other than the people they lived amongst. This was true up to the enlightenment period. From that time until the Shoah, western Jews sought to heighten their connection to their land of residence and minimize their connections with Jews from other places. The Zionist movement was a notable exception to this, but its size and influence were small before WWII.
Another notable American exception to that was Rabbi Mordchai Kalplan. Kaplan defined Judaism in his seminal 1934 work as a "Civilization". He sought in that moment to undo the western Jews self-redefinition and reassert the non-religious components of Jewish life and Judaism.
Which leads us back to our test, what is Judaism- to you?
Now that you have that answer let me ask you something else-
What are you doing about it now?
Judaism is no longer a condition but a choice. - Richard Joel, President of Yeshiva University
No comments:
Post a Comment