Saturday, February 2, 2008

Imagined Communities

A few years ago I was at a conference of Jewish professionals and I attended a breakout session on community. It was oddly enough being conducted by a colleague who was just finishing up his PhD in anthropology and ethnomusicology. I say oddly, because his approach to the subject was far more academic than most of us were prepared for and he must of spent about an hour just trying to get us to understanding the terminology. He then said something that startled most of us. He said that we didn't really know what students were on our campuses. He told us that we could only know the students we had contact with, all of the other students were simply imagined.

What he meant by that was not that the students did not exist, but rather that anything we thought we knew about them was pure supposition. Their likes, dislikes, thoughts about Jewish community and Judaism were simply educated guesses on our part and nothing more. This comes as a shock to most of us in the field, because we like to think we know why people don't come around.

The answers include that we are too social, not social enough, too Jewish, not Jewish enough, too liberal, not liberal enough and so on. But is any of that true? Do we really have any idea what those barriers are that prevent them from joining the intentional communities we create?

Surveys conducted over the last few years reveal that most of our ideas are wrong. What we learn is that for most people the real question is how high is their sense of Jewish identification, and how motivated are they to act on that feeling. People who score high on both axes tend to become very involved. Those who score very low on either, don't.

Of course the secondary question is whether those score in the middle on both can find a micro-community within our larger framework that looks and feels sufficiently familiar to be claimed as their own. This is the moment that our professional skills are tested as we attempted to facilitate this matching process. Do it well and the community expands. Do it poorly and we leave someone with a real barrier to joining the Jewish community and that's not imaginary.

2 comments:

  1. Anderson's idea of "imagined communities" is usually used in reference to nationalism. I think understanding Anderson is important for understanding this idea. Here's a website to check out:
    http://www.nationalismproject.org/what/anderson.htm

    Did you just not want to get too academic, and so you left this out? :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. No reason in particular, just trying to be cognizant of the reader's attention span.

    ReplyDelete