Rabbinic commentators love to slice the commandments (mitzvot) up into categories. There is wide agreement that there are a total of 613, and a number that large just begs to be broken down into smaller groups. For instance there are time bound mitzvot (think Pesach) and not time bound (honor you mother and father). There are positive (you will keep the sabbath) and negative (you will not bear false witness). Then there is my favorite set of categories, mitzvot that make sense, and those that don't. The rabbinic scholars were pretty clear on this, the ones that make sense- make sense. The ones that don't- don't, and you shouldn't spend a lot of time trying to figure it out. See the rabbis figured that God had his reasons, and that they were simply beyond human understanding. God said do it, so we do it. A great example of mitzvot that make no sense are most of the laws of kashrut. However, one could extend from those laws a general observation about the ethical consumption of food. After all, what is a prohibition on cooking a kid in its mother's milk about if not an appeal to the emotional well being of the mother? What else can we say about a commandment to let the land go fallow one year out of seven if not an directive to care for and conserve our resources?
This year I spent a lot of time thinking about what would reside (albeit briefly) upon my Pesach dinner plate. I grew up on a farm and was never unclear on where meat (and for that matter potatoes) came from. Long ago I made peace with the notion that the fat and protein resting on my plate was once a breathing creature. Having said that, like most people who have driven past the feed lot on the 5 I feel a bit uneasy about the provenance of that meat. Kosher meat is meat that has been slaughtered in the ritual manner of slicing through all of the major blood vessels in the neck in one blow, thus reducing the pain and "tearing" of the animal to a minimum (trafe means torn or ripped). But kashrut is silent on the matter of how that animal is raised and what it eats. This led me to seek out grass fed organic kosher meat for our family seder this year. I ended up choosing bison, as much for the experience as anything else.
The meal was fantastic. The combination of family, great food and good conversation made for a truly wonderful evening. Much of what I served was sourced from California (the bison came from Montana) and I felt that I honored an ethical imperative that is contained in the laws of kashrut. But, I would also be the first to tell you that that it is an ethical imperative that is not contained in the text of the commandment and there lots of room for discussion on the matter.
As for myself, I a hoping that Niman ranch meats will consider adding a kosher line to its products. I have a well seasoned cast iron pan just waiting to put a nice crust on a thick steak.
Tuesday, April 22, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment