Thursday, February 28, 2008

Mivchan Amerikai

Mivchan Amerikai is Hebrew for American Test. This is how Israelis describe the multiple choice format for tests so popular here. I am unsure of the origins of the expression, but it always inspires a smile. So, allow me to inflict a small sample upon you now:

Judaism is:
1) a religion
2) an ethnic group
3) a condition
4) a civilization

This question was prompted by the recent poll on religious life in America (see the NYT article here). The poll revealed the degree to which Americans were increasingly changing religious affiliation over the course of their lifetimes. Where once people had largely participated (or abstained from) the religion of their family, it was more common for people to "shop around" for a style of faith and practice that suited them. The biggest net growth was for the unaffiliated, people who did not profess any religious participation at all.

"The presentation of Judaism will be judged by the adequacy of the statement establishing its truth" Eugene Borowitz, Choices in Modern Jewish Thought (Behrman House, 1995)
Judaism is often seen by both Jews and non-Jews as purely a religion. That prompts the question as to what degree we find Judaism as a religion a compelling answer to our theological needs. Our preception of that is directly rooted in how well we understand Judaism to begin with. For the vast majority of us our Jewish education either never was, or ended at age 13. So regardless of what our theological needs are, we are almost universally under-equipped to asses Judaism's usefulness. If we are devoted to the idea of advancing Judaism purely as a religion then we will have to undertake a huge amount of remedial education within the next generation.

Judaism however is not just a religion. In both the ancient and modern nationalist perspective Jews are a people. Whether one subscribes to the biblical narrative or not, the emergence of a distinctive nation state in antiquity is well established in the historical record. The literature, physical remains and legislative work of those kingdoms survived and the descendants of those people have maintained a distinctive language, religious system and set of cultural mores. While these were influenced by the various communities Jews lived in, the rate of assimilation was low and the majority of the Jewish communities had more in common with each other than the people they lived amongst. This was true up to the enlightenment period. From that time until the Shoah, western Jews sought to heighten their connection to their land of residence and minimize their connections with Jews from other places. The Zionist movement was a notable exception to this, but its size and influence were small before WWII.

Another notable American exception to that was Rabbi Mordchai Kalplan. Kaplan defined Judaism in his seminal 1934 work as a "Civilization". He sought in that moment to undo the western Jews self-redefinition and reassert the non-religious components of Jewish life and Judaism.

Which leads us back to our test, what is Judaism- to you?
Now that you have that answer let me ask you something else-
What are you doing about it now?



Judaism is no longer a condition but a choice. - Richard Joel, President
of Yeshiva University

Thursday, February 21, 2008

Total Eclipse

There was a lunar eclipse yesterday. It peaked at about 7PM and if you were in a place with little light pollution and no cloud cover (not around here) you might have even seen the moon turn blood red. There is a blessing in the Jewish tradition for witnessing miracles of creation, it is a thanks to god for creating things of beauty (and wonder) in this world.

I experienced another smaller miracle this week, but not the kind that should be exceptional. I was riding home on Tuesday night and some combination of pothole/rear wheel/chain resulted in my hitting the rain soaked pavement in front of the RSF at 15MPH or so.

Those moments of the fall are so clear while they transpire. I can still recall the slowness with which I felt myself leave the bike and descend to the street. My hands where in front of me and the bike somewhere behind. I remember hitting the pavement with my left side and then sliding for a bit before snapping back into the moment with the sudden realization that I was laying in the middle of a busy street.

I was ok, some scrapes and a lot of bruises, including a fabulous one on the heel of my right hand, still hurt. But I was shaken enough to use BART to cover most of the remaining distance between there and my kitchen table.

What struck me in the aftermath were the people who stopped and offered to help. I didn't have the presence of mind to be as thankful as I should have, so I want to thank them now (whether they read me or not). In the cold wet night on a busy street people in cars and on foot stopped to ask if I was ok, if I needed help and one even brought me a wad of handlebar tape that had peeled off my bike and was laying in the gutter.

The next day (Wednesday) dawned with the threat of rain, and even rained on me during my ride in adding nothing to my recovery -even making me feel more sore. But by lunch the sun had come out clear and bright. Lunch with a good friend was superb and the rest of the day went well. I missed the lunar eclipse, but having seen the compassion of my fellow man I was already a witness to a small miracle and that is the thought I will take into this Shabbat.

Friday, February 15, 2008

Shabbat

Ok, I admit it. I am pulling a blank this week. Part of it is that I have been unsuccessful in catching up on my sleep since going skiing last weekend and the other is that I have had a pretty busy week. The upshot is that the moments of inspiration that I usually have riding my bike to work or talking with students simply have not occurred.

So let me tell you about my plans for Shabbat. First off, for the first time in a month I will be home with my family. I am thinking about making a nice piece of seared tuna (that way we can use the dairy dishes and put butter on the table), some blanched broccoli and perhaps a fritata. There are a couple bottles of red wine gathering dust in the rack, so one of those will come to the table as well. Tomorrow I plan to sleep until my kids come and wake me up (hopefully sometime after 9- but we'll see) and then to spend the day doing almost nothing that I need to do. Who knows, perhaps I can squeeze a ride in. I just registered for a 112 mile ride in May, so I need to get in shape.

It's a three day weekend, the weather is supposed to be great. Don't stay inside trying to catch up on your reading, go out and soak up some of that vitaman D (don't forget your sunscreen) and have a peaceful, relaxing and meaningful Shabbat.

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Jew-ish?

“For me “Israeli’ is the authentic, complete and consummate word for the concept ‘Jewish’! Israeli-ness is the total, perfect and original Judaism, one that should provide answers in all areas of life.”

A.B. Yehoshua

Sleeping on a Wire, David Grossman (FSG, 1993) New York. p.253



I have always loved that quote. It manages to be at once completely provocative and seemingly quite normal. A conversation that I often have with other staff members and students revolves around how Jewish is Berkeley Hillel. The classic rejoinder is, "what does Jewish mean?" Unfortunately I do not have as clear an answer as Mr. Yehoshua.

What I can offer instead is my own 30+ year long struggle to define my own Judaism. The questions I have wrestled with (everything from kashrut to theology) have informed how I live my life now and how I contribute to the education of my children. One thing I have learned is that none of us can offer the other anything more than an example of the struggle. My answers will not be yours and my reasons will not suffice for your life. My professional mission is to encourage each student and staff member to fully engage in that struggle. To bring to it all of the intellectual firepower that they bring to class and to not allow their Judaism to simply sit on a shelf.

The flip side of that is there are those who have a pretty set idea of what Jewish looks like. Whether from a more traditional, or more liberal perspective they seek in Berkeley Hillel a replication of themselves. This is pretty natural since we all seek ourselves in community. After all, how easy is it to become part of a community that is completely foreign? So, how can an institution be both challenging and welcoming? How can we be both home-like and new? That is a challenge that we face every day.

"Lo alecha ham'lacha ligmor,V'lo atah ven chorin l'hibateil mi-menah."
It is not on you to finish the work, but nor are you free to leave it.
Pirkai Avot (Ethics of our Fathers) 2:16

Saturday, February 2, 2008

Imagined Communities

A few years ago I was at a conference of Jewish professionals and I attended a breakout session on community. It was oddly enough being conducted by a colleague who was just finishing up his PhD in anthropology and ethnomusicology. I say oddly, because his approach to the subject was far more academic than most of us were prepared for and he must of spent about an hour just trying to get us to understanding the terminology. He then said something that startled most of us. He said that we didn't really know what students were on our campuses. He told us that we could only know the students we had contact with, all of the other students were simply imagined.

What he meant by that was not that the students did not exist, but rather that anything we thought we knew about them was pure supposition. Their likes, dislikes, thoughts about Jewish community and Judaism were simply educated guesses on our part and nothing more. This comes as a shock to most of us in the field, because we like to think we know why people don't come around.

The answers include that we are too social, not social enough, too Jewish, not Jewish enough, too liberal, not liberal enough and so on. But is any of that true? Do we really have any idea what those barriers are that prevent them from joining the intentional communities we create?

Surveys conducted over the last few years reveal that most of our ideas are wrong. What we learn is that for most people the real question is how high is their sense of Jewish identification, and how motivated are they to act on that feeling. People who score high on both axes tend to become very involved. Those who score very low on either, don't.

Of course the secondary question is whether those score in the middle on both can find a micro-community within our larger framework that looks and feels sufficiently familiar to be claimed as their own. This is the moment that our professional skills are tested as we attempted to facilitate this matching process. Do it well and the community expands. Do it poorly and we leave someone with a real barrier to joining the Jewish community and that's not imaginary.