Ezer Weizman who served as Israel's seventh president (and was the nephew of Israel's first president Chaim Weizman) was well known for his penchant for asking Jews from abroad, "when are you going to make Aliyah?" He asked this question of both billionaires and of visiting college students. He believed firmly that to be a good Zionist you had to move to Israel. This was actually a fairly prevalent view amongst Israelis and also among the pre-state Zionist movement.
I remember the first time I was confronted with this view point. I was living in Arad attending Ulpan (Hebrew language instruction) and one of the instructors introduced me to a young woman who was in training to become a Shalicha (emissary) of the Jewish Agency (a large NGO that provides an array of educational and support services inside Israel and around the Jewish world). She asked my friend if he was planning to move to Israel permanently. Since he had been in Israel for all of a month at that point he said that he was not planning to. She then looked at him and said, "ah so you are not a Zionist". He took issue with that since he considered himself a Zionist, had been active in pro-Israel issues as a student (back during the first Intifada) and thought that his plans for moving to Israel (or not) were really not part of the discussion.
It was from that discussion (and many more like it) that I started think about my own Zionist journey. I did move to Israel, for what I thought was the rest of my life. I lived for 5 years on Kibbutz and savored every moment of it. I returned to America, not bitter- but really grateful for the experience I had.
As a Jewish educator I was often having conversations with others about Israel's role in their lives and its impact on their Judaism. Today I have a Zionist vision for Jews from America. That vision is for every American Jew to spend a year living in Israel.
Why? Because I know that after a year of holidays, political conversations with cab drivers, discussions with religious and non-religious Israelis you will have a set of experiences that will change your Jewish identity. Will you move to Israel permanently (make Aliyah)? I don't know, but you will spend a year wrestling with the question and from that emerge with a stronger, deeper and more thoughtful approach to Jewish and Judaism.
So, let me make a plug now for the Masa scholarship program (link) and an offer to talk to anyone about their thoughts on the matter.
Thursday, March 13, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment